Cosmic Spaghetti

Long on my to-do list has been the spectacular Simeis 147, also known as SH2-240 or the Spaghetti Nebula.  A large supernova remnant (SNR) spanning the border between the Taurus and Auriga constellations, which despite its size is one of the faintest objects in the night sky and therefore not an easy astrophotography target.  Moreover, given my equipment’s field-of-view the large size of the SNR would require a mosaic to fully image, which is generally out of the question here at Fairvale Observatory with the limited clear sky conditions that prevail hereTherefore, for the moment I’ve concentrated on a close-up area of the southern lobe, imaged and processed in HOO narrowband to highlight the beautiful complexity of this cosmic cataclysm that is the product of a massive stellar explosion that took place some 40,000 years ago.

Simeis 147 Location

Furthermore, imaging was not helped by the presence of a waning full moon and even with 10-minute exposures, only very limited detail was evident in the Ha wavelength and none in OIII, thus also making framing tricky.  However, with over 12-hours integration time eventually obtained over four nights and very careful processing, my first image of this wonderful SNR does not disappoint.  I hope to return to this magnificent object again in the future to add more exposures – you really cannot have too many – and perhaps eventually capture this bowl of cosmic spaghetti in its entirety one day too.

Ha Stack 6-hours 30 mins
OIII Stack 5-hours 40 mins
 IMAGING DETAILS
ObjectSimeis 147  AKA SH2-240 or Spaghetti Nebula
ConstellationTaurus
Distance3,000 light-years
Size Total object +3.0o
Apparent MagnitudeExtemely faint
  
Scope William Optics GT81 + Focal Reducer FL 382mm  f4.72
MountSW AZ-EQ6 GT + EQASCOM computer control & Cartes du Ciel
GuidingWilliam Optics 50mm guide scope
 + Starlight Xpress Lodestar X2 camera & PHD2 guiding
CameraZWO1600MM-Cool mono  CMOS sensor
 FOV 2.65o x 2.0o Resolution 2.05”/pix  Max. image size 4,656 x 3,520 pix   
EFWZWOx8 EFW & 31mm Chroma 3nm Ha, OPIII & SII filters 
Capture & ProcessingAstro Photography Tool + PHD2 + Deep Sky Stacker, PixInsight v1.8.8-12, Photoshop CC, Topaz AI Denoise
Image Location              & OrientationCentre  RA 05:41:28.486      DEC +28:01:51.616                      Left = North  Top = West    
Exposures39 x 10 min Ha, 34 x 10 min & 9 x 10 min SII Total Integration Time: 12 hr 10 min     
 @ 139 Gain   21  Offset @ -20oC    
Calibration5 x 10 min Darks, 15 x  Ha, OIII, SII flats and Flat Darks      @ ADU 25,000
Location & DarknessFairvale Observatory – Redhill – Surrey – UK        Typically Bortle 5-6
Date & Time21st December 2021 + 4th, 5th & 6th January 2022  @ +19.00h  
WeatherApprox. <2oC   RH >=80%              🌙 96% → 21%

2021 The Year In Pictures

Every year since 2014 I’ve published a retrospective blog of my astrophotgraphy year just ending called Reflections. It’s been a useful task that enables me to bring together the best and sometimes the worst of my images, in order to consider the good and bad points + progress made + set some objectives for the coming year. Eight years on, after which I believe I’ve now reached at least a respectable level of imaging and processing, I’ve decided to stop this format for the time being.

Notwithstanding, at this time of the year I also produce an astrophotography calendar for members of my family, which consists of the better images from the year just ending; I think they like them and certainly all use the calendar during the coming year. Moreover, I also recently started to compile a video of the said calendar images set to appropriate music, which we all watch together prior to seeing the actual calendar. It’s a great way to present the images, which look really stunning on today’s large Smart TV’s and is fun to watch with the family too.

The video for this last year 2021 can be viewed on YouTube HERE and below is a brief very general overview of each image. More detailed background information and imaging details for those interested can be found in relevant blogs posted on this site during the past year.

2022 CALENDAR

A new set of filters, improved processing techniques and access to data from a telescope at a dark sky site in New Mexico, USA (shown by an asterisk *) contributed to an exciting astrophotography year in 2021.                  

FRONT COVERThe Carnival of Animals: Special processing of the inner region of the Rosette Nebula highlights the ‘animals’ or Bok Globules – clouds of dust undergoing gravitational collapse as part of the process of new star formation.  
JANUARYLDN-1250 Dark Nebula*: Dark or absorption nebulae are a type of interstellar cloud which are so dense they obscure or absorb visible light emitted from objects behind or within and thereby contrast with the general light flux of the Universe as dark areas.  
FEBRUARYCTB-1 Supernova Remnant*: The overall structure of this supernova remnant is that of a circular shell, with a conspicuous rupture towards the north (lower right of image).  The main red Ha-shell is composed of multiple interlocking filament limbs, with a blue / green OIII arc along one side.  
MARCHJellyfish Nebula: Locatedin the Gemini constellation some 5,000 light years from Earth, this is a remnant of a supernova that took place during the past 30,000 years. With a diameter of 70 light-years, the object is visually speaking nearly twice the size of a full moon.     
APRILMarkarian’s Chain: The Virgo cluster consists of more than 2,000 galaxies, within which Markarian’s Chain forms a J-curve string of bright galaxies that share a common motion through space.    
MAYM13 Great Globular Cluster of Hercules*: Consisting of several hundred thousand stars and 145 light-years in diameter, M13 is considered to be the finest cluster in the Northern Hemisphere.  
JUNECave Nebula*: Located along the plane of the Milky Way is the diffuse emission nebula referred to as the Cave Nebula.  The Cave at the centre is critically located at the boundary of the Cepheus molecular cloud and the hot, young stars which ionize the surrounding gases to great effect.  
JULYOrion Widefield: Framed around the area of Orion’s Belt, the Horsehead Nebula and the Great Orion Nebula, look hard and the refection nebula M78 can also be seen in the lower left corner.    
AUGUSTElephant’s Trunk Nebula*: A very large emission nebula, the so-called Elephant’s Trunk Nebula is rightly viewed as one of astrophotography’s most iconic images. The ‘trunk’ itself dominates the centre of this image and is illuminated from behind by a bright star forming region.  
SEPTEMBERM31 Andromeda Galaxy: The full benefit of new filters, improved guiding, clear skies over 6-nights and extensive use of new processing techniques can be seen in my best image yet of Andromeda.      
OCTOBERButterfly Nebula: Situatedwithin the Orion Arm of the Milky Way is the Gamma Cygni nebula, a diffuse emission nebula surrounding the star Sadr.  Either side of the dark rift which divides the image from top to bottom are two large bright areas that together form the so-called Butterfly.  
NOVEMBERM33 Triangulum Galaxy: Like it’s neighbour Andromeda, better data and processing has produced an exciting new image of M33 this year, the red areas highlight Ha-rich star-forming regions  
DECEMBERFlying Bat & Giant Squid Nebula*: This very faint OIII emission nebula Ou4 required an imaging time of 40-hours.  For obvious reasons Ou4 has become known as the Giant Squid Nebula which, moreover, lies within the much larger SH2-129 HII emission region or the Flying Bat Nebula.     

HAPPY NEW YEAR + CLEAR SKIES IN 2022

The Journey

A year after taking up astronomy as a hobby, at the behest of my elder daughter I started this blog in 2014.  Describing the objective and content of the blog I adopted the strapline “A personal discovery of the Universe through astronomy and astrophotography”, which could also be described as a journey.  In reality it’s been an adventure consisting of two threads: the knowledge and related science of astronomy and the challenge of astrophotography.   As we on Earth pass through space whilst at the same time rotating 360o each year around the sun our view of the night sky changes month-by-month, inevitably returning to the same perspective each 365-days.  Against this background I therefore often return to certain objects every few years hopefully armed with new astrophotography skills in pursuit of an even better image.

Following such a path I’ve already imaged M31 the Andromeda Galaxy on four separate occasions since 2015, each time enthralled by the majesty and beauty of this barred spiral galaxy.  Notwithstanding, it was clear to me that there was significant scope for improvement of the previous images with both better data and processing. Since the last attempt in October 2019 a myriad of positive developments have taken place of which perhaps three stand out: multi-star guiding, the purchase of Chroma filters and in particular the use of PixInsight image for processing – all have been game changers, so much so that reprocessing that image now also looks good – see below.

 However, whilst the said progress has already been transformative to my astrophotography during the past year, inevitabky it is imaging conditions that play the most critical role, especially in England.   Fortunately during this autumn in both October and November for once the new moon coincided with clear skies, providing no less than six nights over which I was able to obtain almost 12-hours of some of perhaps my best ever data.  Based on this I’ve been careful to apply my best new processing skills and am thankful that the final HaLRGB image has turned out very well.  In particular, the dust lanes stand out against the bright core and surrounding blue intergalactic dust and gases, which are themselves punctuated by the bright red regions rich in Ha light. 

In the blogs that accompanied previous Andromeda images I’ve often referred to the galaxy as a neighbour of the Milky Way but really we are part of the same family known as the Local Group.  Some 10-million light years in diameter, more than 30 galaxies form two collections around the two largest galaxies of Andromeda and the Milky Way.  Gravitational forces play the central role in controlling this group, especially Andromeda which is itself moving towards the Milky Way at about 70 miles per second and is destined to merge in about +/- 4 billion years; recent studies indicate that an outer halo of stars extending up to 2-billion light years from Andromeda may be in the influence of the galaxy, suggesting this event may already have started!

Thereby my personal journey of astrophotography is set to continue somewhat in parallel with that of Andromeda, which will I am sure lead to further hopefully even better images of this exciting deep sky object that is perfect for my equipment – after all we’re getting closer at the rate of 2,207,520,000 miles each year!                     

 IMAGING DETAILS
ObjectM31 the Andromeda Galaxy.
ConstellationAndromeda
Distance2.5 million light-years
Size3.2o  x 1o  or 220,000  light-years  
Apparent Magnitude+3.44
  
Scope William Optics GT81 + Focal Reducer FL 382mm  f4.72
MountSW AZ-EQ6 GT + EQASCOM computer control & Cartes du Ciel
GuidingWilliam Optics 50mm guide scope
 + Starlight Xpress Lodestar X2 guide camera & PHD2 guiding
CameraZWO1600M M-Cool mono  CMOS sensor
 FOV 2.65o x 2.0o Resolution 2.05”/pix  Max. image size 4,656 x 3,520 pix   
EFWZWO x8 EFW + Chroma LRGB & Ha OIII SII 3nm filters 
Capture & ProcessingAstro Photography Tool , Deep Sky Stacker, PixInsight 1.8.8-8, Photoshop CS3 & Topaz AI Denoise
Image Location              & OrientationOriginal image centre  RA 00:42:48      DEC 41:15:05                      Final image rotated 180o  i.e. Bottom = North + 5% crop
ExposuresL 71 x 60 sec  R17  G 20  B  27 x 300 sec  Ha 35 x 600 sec Total time: 11hr 46 minutes   
 @ 139 Gain   21  Offset @ -20oC    
CalibrationDarks 5 x 600 sec + 5 x 300 sec + 60 x 60 sec HaLRGB Flats & Dark Flats  x15 each    @ ADU 25,000
Location & DarknessFairvale Observatory – Redhill – Surrey – UK        Typically Bortle 5-6
Date & Time1st 5th 6th 8th 9th  October & 4th November 2021 @ +/-19.00h  
WeatherApprox. 14o to 5oC   RH >=65% to +85%             🌙 New Moon

The Well & The Butterfly

Located within the Orion Arm of the Milky Way galaxy is the Gamma Cygni nebula, a diffuse emission nebula that surrounds the star of the same name, otherwise better known as Sadr.  Moreover, this large area forms part of an even bigger HII-region that is mainly (80%) located in the north and east quadrants of the so-called Cygnus Cross, which is defined by the stars Deneb – Sadr – Delta Cygni – Albireo – Aljanah (see below). 

This vast area passes directly high overhead at this time the year before disappearing behind the house roofline in the early morning hours and has already provided many exciting imaging opportunities for me in the past.  The heart (not the centre) of the region is the supergiant star Sadr and I first imaged this area in autumn 2015 using my modded DSLR camera.  A return visit was therefore long overdue and this time I set out to better capture the so-called Butterfly Nebula in narrowband wavelengths.

The resulting data has been processed to good effect as an SHO image (see top-of-the-page) using the Hubble Palette techniques.  Other than the dominant supergiant star Sadr and widespread colourful nebulosity, two significant features are worthy of note in the final image.  Either side of the almost central dark rift that divides the image laterally, are two large bright areas which together form the ‘wings’ of the so-called Butterfly Nebula IC 1318-C (right = south) and IC 1318-B (left = north).  Furthermore, just beyond the Butterfly’s left wing north of Sadr is the young, bright open star cluster NGC 6910.

Finished well with submersible water pump & floodlight (turned off for astronomy!)

I’m very pleased with this image, which is my first since the end of March, in part because nowadays I take an astronomy break during the long late spring / summer days when astronomical darkness is largely absent. However, this year the pause has been protracted as the patio on which Fairvale Observatory is situated was re-laid, during which a hitherto unknown water well was discovered. Thereafter one thing led to another and turned into a summer project to recommission the well, thus delaying completion of the patio.  As a result I’ve only recently been able to reinstate the astronomy equipment, a job that is still ongoing. The new patio is firm and flat, providing a much better surface for the mount than before and I’m hopeful that once recalibration is completed will result in improved tracking results – watch this space!

 IMAGING DETAILS
ObjectIC1318-B & IC1318-C  Gamma Cygni  Nebula or Butterfly Nebula NGC 6910 Open cluster
ConstellationCygnus
Distance3,700 light-years
Size 1Approximately 100 light-years
Apparent MagnitudeVaries  
  
Scope William Optics GT81 + Focal Reducer FL 382mm  f4.72
MountSW AZ-EQ6 GT + EQASCOM computer control & Cartes du Ciel
GuidingWilliam Optics 50mm guide scope
 + Starlight Xpress Lodestar X2 camera & PHD2 guiding
CameraZWO1600MM-Cool mono  CMOS sensor
 FOV 2.65o x 2.0o Resolution 2.05”/pix  Max. image size 4,656 x 3,520 pix   
EFWZWOx8 EFW & 31mm Chroma LRGB filters 
Capture & ProcessingAstro Photography Tool + PHD2 +  Deep Sky Stacker, PixInsight v1.8.8-8, Photoshop CS3, Topaz Denoise
Image Location              & OrientationCentre  RA 20:25:20.492      DEC +40:11:20.970                      Left = North     
Exposures21 x 300 sec Ha, OIII, SII Total Integration Time: 5hr 15 min     
 @ 139 Gain   21  Offset @ -20oC    
Calibration5 x 300 sec Darks 15 x  Flats & 10 x Dark Flats  Ha, OIII, SII  @ ADU 25,000
Location & DarknessFairvale Observatory – Redhill – Surrey – UK        Typically Bortle 5-6
Date & Time6th & 7th September  2021  @ +21.00h  
WeatherApprox. >=17oC   RH >=45%                  🌙 New Moon

          

Dark Art

Somewhat tongue-in cheek, astrophotography is often referred to as something of a dark art and to be fair it sometimes seems that way, particularly when it comes to processing.  My main interests in astrophotography are Deep Sky Objects such as emission nebulae, galaxies and planetary nebula but have long aspired to capture a more elusive category that abounds throughout the Universe – dark nebula.

Popular with astrophotographers, emission nebulae consist of vast clouds of ionised gases and regions of interstellar dust which reflect light from the said gases and or from stars and stellar nurseries that lie within – depending on their make-up the results are colourful in both broadband and narrowband wavelengths.  Dark or absorption nebulae are also a type of interstellar cloud but are so dense they completely obscure and / or soak-up visible light emitted from objects behind or within, which as a result contrasts with general light flux of the Universe forming large dark regions.  Because of their darkness they are usually faint, hard to see and moreover, difficult to image, especially from locations with light pollution.

The Horsehead Nebula is a dark nebula that has formed a part of my previous images but I’ve only imaged an isolated dark nebula once before – Barnard 142-3, which for obvious reasons is also known as the E-nebula (see above & here).  Larger more complex dark nebulae require much darker skies to image than prevail at Fairvale Observatory, such as in New Mexico, USA where the Deep Sky West observatory is located and on this occasion has produced my first ‘serious’ image of a stand-alone dark nebula.

Cepheus & the aproximate location of LDN 1250 image indicated by the red square

Lynds Dark Nebula (LDN) catalogue of dark nebulae was compiled by the eponymous Beverly T. Lynds in 1962 and is based on the study of red and blue photographic prints from the National Geographic-Palomar Observatory Sky Atlas. Situated in the north close to Polaris, the constellation of Cepheus has a number of dark nebulae, of which LDN 1250 is part of a huge complex of dark nebula surrounded by dust and scattered light from the stars of Cepheus.

LDN 1250 luminance – RGB wavelengths are also strong

Imaged here in LRGB the features come out well in all wavelengths, however, such are the subtleties of the dark nebula components I found processing difficult and required plenty of ‘dark art’ techniques.  The final image at the top of the page shows to good effect the main dark nebula, togeher with widespread but less opaque nebulosity and star colours, as well as some distant galaxies lurking in the background that together has produced a satisfying and very interesting outcome.

 IMAGING DETAILS
ObjectLDN 1250 & 1251
ConstellationCepheus
Distance1,000 light years
SizeMain nebula approximately 1o  ~ 17 light-years
Apparent Magnitude–  
  
Scope Takahashi FSQ 106  FL 530mm  f/5  +  Moonlight Nightcrawler focuser  
MountParamount MyT
GuidingYes
CameraQSI 683-WSG8    KAF-8300 full frame CCD sensor   5.4nm pixels  
 FOV 1.94o x 1.46o   Resolution 2.1”/pix.   Image array 3326 x 2,507 pix   
ProcessingDeep Sky Stacker,  PixInsight v1.8.8-7,  Photoshop CS3, Topaz Denoise
Image Location &             OrientationCentre  –  RA 22:28:54.702      DEC +75:09:45.158                    
North = Up
 
Exposures23L  + 18R +  16G + 17B x 900 secs  @ -15C
Total Integration Time: 18hr 30min     
Calibration41 x 900 secs Darks   x 50 Bias  &  x16 LRGB Flats   
Location & DarknessDeep Sky West – amateur hosting facility near Rowe, New Mexico  – USA    SQM Typically >= 21.7
Date & TimeQ4  2020    

 

Cosmic Eruption

Originally thought to be a planetary nebula, Abell included this object in his catalogue as Abell-85 but later in 1971 it was revised as a supernova remnant (SNR) and renamed CTB-1, thus also denoting it as a radio source.  The overall structure is a circular shell with a conspicuous rupture towards the north (bottom right of image).  The main red Ha-shell is composed of multiple interlocking filament limbs, with a blue / green OIII arc along one side (see main image above).

I experimented extensively processing the data because of its overall complexity and is an interesting object, which is therfore also presented below as greyscale Ha-wavelength only and starless versions.  The main Ha and OIII data is shot at long 1,800 second exposures, which together with RGB adds up to a whopping 29 hours of integration time. However, CTB-1 is an extremely faint object, which probably still requires considerably more time – I’ve seen somebody else’s 61-hour integration which they described as “not enough” and despite the quality of their image I’d probably have to agree.  

CTB-1 is a very exciting object, which might have been what Douglas Adams had in mind when creating Milliways or The Restaurant At The End Of The Universe in the Hitchhiker’s Guide, from which such spectacular events could be ordered to view with your meal! 

 IMAGING DETAILS
ObjectCTB-1  (Abell-85)
ConstellationCassiopeia
Distance10,000  light-years
Size 35 arcminutes ~  100 light-years
Apparent Magnitude–  
  
Scope Takahashi FSQ 106  FL 530mm  f/5  +  Moonlight Nightcrawler focuser  
MountParamount MyT
GuidingYes
CameraQSI 683-WSG8    KAF-8300 full frame CCD sensor   5.4nm pixels  
 FOV 1.94o x 1.46o   Resolution 2.1”/pix.   Image array 3326 x 2,507 pix   
ProcessingDeep Sky Stacker,  PixInsight v1.8.8-8,  Photoshop CS3
Image Location &             OrientationCentre  –  RA 23:59:19.402      DEC +62:25:39.406   
North = bottom right                    
Exposures29 Ha &  20 OIII x 1,800 secs  @ -15C 18 R  17 G  19 B x 300 secs Total Integration Time: 29hr     
Calibration48 x 1,800 secs Darks* x47 Bias  &  x16 HaOIII +LRGB Flats *RGB scaled to 300sec  
Location & DarknessDeep Sky West – amateur hosting facility near Rowe, New Mexico  – USA    SQM Typically >= 21.7
Date & TimeQ3  2020    

Two’s Company

For good reason spring is known as “galaxy season” by astronomers but during this period, shortly before astronomical darkness inevitably disappears for summer, there’s also another show in town.  Closer to home in the denser extremities of our galaxy, over 150 globular clusters have so far been identified orbiting above and below the plane of the Milky Way within the galactic halo.  Globular clusters consist of hundreds of thousands of tightly packed stars that are surely one of the more enigmatic features of astronomy, as we now know that similar clusters also are associated with other galaxies throughout the Universe.  Whilst the formation of globular clusters is poorly understood, we do know that at 10.0 to 13.5 billion years they are very old.  Given their age, location and density, it seems that globular clusters formed under very different circumstances to the more recent dispersed star clusters.

Image Setting / Location

 Sagittarius and Ophiuchus brim with globular clusters but at the higher latitude here at Fairvale Observatory it is necessary to view those around the regions of Canes Venatici, Virgo or Coma Berenices; the Great Cluster of M13 and others such as M92 and NGC 6229 located in the aforesaid Hercules constellation move into a better view later during early summer. Having previously imaged a number of these clusters in the past, this spring I looked around for something new and different, which I found in the name of M53 (Above + left of centre – main image top of the page) .  In this case it turned out to be two for the price of one, as with careful framing it was possible to include a second globular cluster, NGC 5053 (Below + right of centre – main image top of the page).

True Orientation (top = North) + 30% crop – Image Rotated 90 degrees clockwise

Located in the southern area of the Coma Berenices constellation, M53 (Above left of centre – main image, top of the page) is some 58,000 light years from Earth.  Containing some 500,000 metal-poor stars, the cluster equates to 13 arc minutes of sky or about 220 light years in diameter, with an estimated age of 12.67 billion years.  Just over 1o east of M53, NGC 5053 is 53,500 light-years away, with an apparent size of 10.5 arc minutes or 160 light-years.  Although classified as a globular cluster, NGC 5053 is more irregular and dispersed in nature without a distinct bright core and is therefore dimmer than its neighbour, making it more difficult to image.

M35 Full Crop

All-in-all I believe these two globular clusters, combined with the star studded background that just includes the binary Diadem star (Upper edge + right of middle – main image, top of the page) southwest of M53, altogether makes for a rich and interesting final image.

 IMAGING DETAILS
ObjectM53 & NGC 5053
ConstellationComa Berenices
DistanceApprox.. 58,000 & 53,000 light-years
Size  13.0 & 10.5 arc minutes
Apparent Magnitude+8.33 & +10.00    
  
Scope William Optics GT81 + Focal Reducer FL 382mm  f4.72
MountSW AZ-EQ6 GT + EQASCOM computer control & Cartes du Ciel
GuidingWilliam Optics 50mm guide scope
 + Starlight Xpress Lodestar X2 camera & PHD2 guiding
CameraZWO1600MM-Cool mono  CMOS sensor
 FOV 2.65o x 2.0o Resolution 2.05”/pix  Max. image size 4,656 x 3,520 pix   
EFWZWOx8 EFW & 31mm Chroma LRGB filters 
Capture & ProcessingAstro Photography Tool + PHD2 +  Deep Sky Stacker, PixInsight v1.8.8-7, Photoshop CS3, Topaz Denoise
Image Location &          OrientationCentre  RA 13:13:59.405      DEC +18:01:48.627                      Lower Left Corner = North   Top = South West    
Exposures55 x 180 sec L , 34 x 180 sec R,  30 x 180 sec G&B Total Integration Time: 7hr 27 min     
 @ 139 Gain   21  Offset @ -20oC    
Calibration10 x 60 sec Darks  15 x  LRGB Flats & Dark Flats         @ ADU 25,000
Location & DarknessFairvale Observatory – Redhill – Surrey – UK        Typically Bortle 5-6
Date & Time13th, 15th & 16th April 2021  @ +21.00h  
WeatherApprox. <5oC   RH >55%                  🌙 6% waxing

                

Galactic Stepping Stones

The Virgo Cluster consists of more than 2,000 galaxies, which unfortunately are optically too much for my small William Optics GT81 telescope individually.  However, one of several sub-groups within the Virgo Cluster forms a striking J-curve shape that does make for a pleasing LRGB image.  Discovered and named after the Armenian astrophysicist Benjamin Markarian, Markarian’s Chain is a string of bright galaxies that share a common motion through space.  I first imaged the Chain in April 2015 using a modded DSLR and then again in April 2017, as my first LRGB image with the then new ZWO ASI1600MM-Cool camera but with integration times of less than 1-hour on both occasions, the resulting images were far from ideal.  On this occasion using my new Chroma LRGB filters for the first time I was determined to do better.

The new filters and nearly 7-hours integration time has resulted in a much more dynamic and detailed image, which I believe now does justice to this spectacular group of galaxies.  Analysis of the image using Astrometry.net shows just how crowded this area of Virgo is with galaxies (see annotated image above) but it is Markarian’s Chain that inevitably stands out together with a few other adjacent galaxies.

  • Large 10th magnitude M84 & M86 galaxies at the western end of the Chain dominate the image.  M84 is the object with the highest blue shift in the Messier catalogue, which is a result of its rapid movement (244km/sec) towards the centre of the Virgo Cluster and us.  At the centre of M84 is a 1.5 billion solar mass black hole.
  • NGC 4420 & NGC 4388 – by comparison these edge-on galaxies together with even smaller NGC 4413 & NGC 4425 seem to frame the larger M84 and M86.   
  • Next along the Chain is a pair of interacting galaxies, the smaller round shaped NGC 4435 and NGC 4438 with its distorted disk, known as “The Eyes”.                             
  • As the Chain starts to turn, some 20’ along is NGC 4458 and its partner, the 11th magnitude elliptical NGC 4461.
  • The final section of the Chain consists first of NGC 4473, its brightness generated by a supermassive black hole – at 100 million solar masses its diameter of 4.46au which would stretch from the Sun to the asteroid belt!  Thereafter the 11.4 magnitude barred lenticular galaxy NGC 4477 defines the north eastern extremity of Markarian’s Chain.
  • As previously noted, there are many other galaxies in this part of the Virgo Cluster.  Perhaps most notable though is M87, from which the first ever image of a black hole was the obtained in 2019 – consisting of some 6.5 billion solar masses.

             

All-in-all Markarian’s Chain makes for a rewarding image using my small telescope combined with the new Chroma filters.  Such is the nature of the image the galaxies might also suggest a string of pearls or perhaps galactic stepping stones – metaphorically leading to the next phase of my astroimaging journey.

 IMAGING DETAILS
ObjectMarkarian’s Chain
ConstellationVirgo & Coma Berenices
Distance50 – 55 million light-years
Size  ~2.5o total
Apparent MagnitudeVaries +10 to +12 approx.  
  
Scope William Optics GT81 + Focal Reducer FL 382mm  f4.72
MountSW AZ-EQ6 GT + EQASCOM computer control & Cartes du Ciel
GuidingWilliam Optics 50mm guide scope
 + Starlight Xpress Lodestar X2 camera & PHD2 guiding
CameraZWO1600MM-Cool mono  CMOS sensor
 FOV 2.65o x 2.0o Resolution 2.05”/pix  Max. image size 4,656 x 3,520 pix   
EFWZWOx8 EFW & 31mm Chroma LRGB filters 
Capture & ProcessingAstro Photography Tool + PHD2 +  Deep Sky Stacker, PixInsight v1.8.8-7, Photoshop CS3, Topaz Denoise
Image Location &           OrientationCentre  RA 12:27:46.65      DEC +13:03:06.44  @21.30h                      Left = North     
Exposures100 x 60 sec L , 54 x 60 sec R,  55 x 60 sec G&B Total Integration Time: 6hr 44 min     
 @ 139 Gain   21  Offset @ -20oC    
Calibration10 x 60 sec Darks  15 x  LRGB Flats & Dark Flats         @ ADU 25,000
Location & DarknessFairvale Observatory – Redhill – Surrey – UK        Typically Bortle 5-6
Date & Time5th & 6th April 2021  @ +21.00h  
WeatherApprox. <2oC   RH >=45%                  🌙 30% waning

Rosette Nebula – Chroma First Light

The history of astrophotography will record a period of rapid innovation during the past decade, amongst which one of the stand-out developments has been that of the CMOS sensor based camera, notably the ZWO ASI1600MM-Cool (see below).  Just look at any astrophotography website such as Astrobin and it won’t take long to find an image taken with this camera such is its popularity.  It is this very camera that I was fortunate to purchase in December 2016 shortly after its release and has been the core of my astrophotography set-up ever since. 

I have generally been very happy with the results achieved with the ZWO camera, although an issue sometimes occurs when imaging large stars, so called ‘star bloating’.  There are a number of theories discussed ad nauseam online why this might occur, of which microlensing and / or diffraction seems most likely and probably relates to either – the sensor, sensor cover or filters.  Since beginning with the ZWO camera I’ve used their excellent matching EFW with LRGB and 7nm narrowband filters.  Notwithstanding, the filters are considered to be somewhat ‘low end’ by the aficionados of such things and after living with the ZWO filters for some time, at considerable cost I recently decided to upgrade to a set of Chroma 31mm filters – LRGB + 3nm narrowband.  Together with Astrodon, Chroma filters are generally considered to be the best and my expectations were therefore high.

Being unmounted I’d previously found the ZWO filters tricky to install using the small screws and fibre washers supplied.  At 3mm Chroma are physically 1mm thicker than ZWO filters and also need to be fitted in a specific direction, which is ‘letters up’ or with top of the ID letters on the side of the filter facing towards the sensor; this is disputed by the manufacturer but there’s substantial first-hand experience online that suggests otherwise.  With these issues in mind I sought out bespoke filter masks and longer M2 6mm screws to hold the thicker filters firmly in place.  The 3D printed masks from Buckeyestargazer in the USA did a great job securing the filters and are better than those from ZWO – the internal edge of the mask forms an L-shaped ledge into which the filter fits snuggly.  Ready to go, I then had to wait nearly 4-months before the clouds parted to try out these expensive pieces of glass and then it was a full moon – I often wonder if astrophotography is a good hobby to choose in the United Kingdom but it’s too late now?

Chroma filters secured with Buckeyestargazer masks and ready to go

Given the presence of the moon it therefore had to be suitable narrowband target and after three years since I’d last imaged this object it was an opportunity to have another go at NGC 2244 AKA the Rosette Nebula, though being late February there was limited time each night before the object sunk low behind trees on the western horizon; coincidentally the ZWO ASI1600MM-Cool First Light in early 2017 was also the Rosette.  Before starting serious imaging I first tried some test shots to make sure everything worked OK and immediately discovered that the change from 7nm to 3nm had a significant impact on light gathering, thus requiring greater exposure times of an unprecedented 10 minutes.  Not surprisingly this was also apparent when taking flats which increased exposure time of up to x10 longer in duration compared to the ZWO filters; conversely preliminary but limited tests on the broadband filters seem to indicate greater transparency and thus shorter exposures, time will tell if this is correct.

So was it all worth it?  I’m very pleased with the final image which was processed using the SHO Hubble Palette with PixInsight and Photoshop (see top of the page).  There are a number of significant bright stars in and around the Rosette which the Chroma filters have handled well but overall it is the more delicate tone that has been achieved which is most pleasing.  Fundamentally the 3nm filters have produced a more subtle quality to the overall image and in particular the nebulosity.  In addition, applying Hartmut Bornemann’s excellent colour calibration script AutoColor for the first time (see Visible Dark’s video tutorial here) has resulted in a soft but exciting colour palette. 

Subsequently I have focussed on the inner region of the nebula which contains the so-called ‘Carnival of Animals’ (see above), which has been cropped and reprocessed individually to show-off the ‘animals’ or Bok globules –   named after the Dutch-American astronomer Bart Bok, who in 1947 proposed that these dark nebula indicated clouds of dust undergoing gravitational collapse as part of the process of new star formation, which has since been confirmed.  In conclusion I’d therefore say that despite the obstacles, issues and long wait, on the evidence so far the addition of the Chroma filters to my set-up has been very successful – transformative in fact.  Now I wonder if they make something that removes the clouds?  

 IMAGING DETAILS
ObjectNGC 2244 + 2337 + 2238 + 2239 + 2246  AKA the Rosette Nebula
ConstellationMonoceros
Distance5,200 light-years
Size65 light-years
Apparent Magnitude9
  
Scope William Optics GT81 + Focal Reducer FL 382mm  f4.72
MountSW AZ-EQ6 GT + EQASCOM computer control & Cartes du Ciel
GuidingWilliam Optics 50mm guide scope
 + Starlight Xpress Lodestar X2 camera & PHD2 guiding
CameraZWO1600MM-Cool mono  CMOS sensor
 FOV 2.65o x 2.0o Resolution 2.05”/pix  Max. image size 4,656 x 3,520 pix   
EFWZWO EFW + Chroma Ha, OIII & SII 3nm filters 
Capture & ProcessingAstro Photography Tool + PHD2 +  Deep Sky Stacker & Photoshop CS3
Image Location              & OrientationCentre  RA 06:31:52.688      DEC 04:58:11.11                        Top = North     
Exposures12 x 600 sec  Ha & SII  11 x 600 sec OIII Total Time:  5hr 50 min   
 @ 139 Gain   21  Offset @ -20oC    
Calibration5 x 600 sec Ha + OIII + SII   Darks 20 x 1/4000 sec Bias  &  15 x  Ha + OIII + SII Flats & Dark Flats               @ ADU 25,000
Location & DarknessFairvale Observatory – Redhill – Surrey – UK        Typically Bortle 5-6
Date & Time26th 27th 28th February 2021  @ +21.15h  
WeatherApprox. <5oC   RH >=65%                  🌙 100% Full Moon

Orion In A New Light

In ancient history Orion’s stars were considered to form a pattern that resembled a hunter holding a club above with his right arm and a shield in front with his left.  The appearance of Orion each year marks the highlight of the astronomy for many including me but for the second year running months of continuous cloud have precluded any astronomy since October; I note from comments online far-and-wide that this phenomenon has prevailed across much of the northern hemisphere, no doubt resulting in a lot of unhappy astronomers.

The Anantomy of Orion

Finally the clouds briefly relented over Fairvale Observatory in February but only for a few hours each time, thus eliminating the possibility of imaging with a CMOS mono camera.  Faced with these problems I therefore returned to my somewhat neglected modded Canon 550D camera and suitable lenses for appropriate widefield compositions, in order to image some classic targets around the Orion constellation in a broader context.  Having first whetted my appetite with the Samyang 135 f2 and its large 9.45o x 6.30o FOV to successfully image the iconic area that encompasses Orion’s belt, the Horsehead Nebula and M42 (see Going Big), it was time to go really big in order to capture the entire constellation literally and figuratively in a new light.

Seven bright stars define the area which outlines the torso and upper legs of Orion the Hunter: Betelgeuse, Bellatrix, Rigel and Saiph at the top and bottom, connected across the centre by his ‘belt’ formed from Alnitak, Alnilam and Mintaka.  The H-shape thus created by these stars is a familiar sight over the winter months but like so many asterisms of the night sky all is not what it seems.  Plotting the distance from Earth of each star it is immediately obvious that their spatial relationship significantly changes the shape of the constellation compared to what as we perceive by eye.  It is a sobering thought that with the passage of time those asterisms familiar to astronomers today will look very different in the future as the stars move though space and therefore continue to change their relative positions, look and shape.          

StarBetelgeuseBellatrixRigelSaiphAlnitakAlnilamMintaka
Distance from Earth* (light years)  643  243  772  724  800  1,359  900
*Source: Royal Greenwich Observatory

Click HERE for annotated version of the Orion Constellation in 3D ref. Space Science Telescope Instititue

The Canon ‘Nifty Fifty’ 50mm f1.8 fixed aperture lens is perfect for an ultra widefield image of Orion. Whilst the glass is excellent, focus leaves a lot to be desired and once achieved needs to be secured with tape

Aside from the said visual perspective of Orion, like so much of space we only see a fraction of what is really present in the Universe but can nevertheless often be disclosed by astrophotography.  And so I next decided to image the entirety of Orion, this time with a basic Canon 1.8 50mm lens – the so called “nifty fifty”- with the purpose of capturing in one shot the constellation with which we are all familiar, together with vast spectacular HII-regions that encompass much of the constellation but usually remain unseen. This camera-lens combination provides an enormous 25.5o x 17.0o field-of-view (x7 > Samyang lens, x83 William Optics GT81!) albeit with lower resolution, which perfectly encompasses most of Orion and therefore the entire arc of Barnard’s Loop on the left and the Angelfish Nebula (Orion’s “head”) located above and between Betelgeuse and Bellatrix. 

Above: Orion constellation from Fairvale Observatory 24th December 2014 (Left) compared with long exposure image + modded camera 10th February 2020 (right)

Barnard’s Loop is an emission nebula, forming part of the Orion Molecular Cloud Complex which also contains the dark Horsehead and bright Great Orion Nebulae M42.  The Loop is believed to have originated from a supernova explosion about 2 million years ago, which is now ionized by stars from within and around the Orion Nebula and takes the form of a large arc centred approximately on the Orion Nebula. Discovered and photographed by E. E. Barnard in 1894, this vast feature extends over some about 600 arcminutes when viewed from Earth or physically up to 300 light years across, depending on the distance from Earth.

The Angelfish Nebula SH2-264 is centred on the young star cluster of Lamda Orionis, of which Meissa is the brightest. An HII-region with an apparent size of 5 degrees and actual size of 150 light years, it is also an emission nebula that is energised by the aforesaid star cluster and is considered to form the so-called head of Orion.

Having previously imaged notable parts throughout Orion, I’ve long wanted to capture the full extent of this wonderful constellation in all its glory and am very pleased with the outcome on this occasion.

DSLR IMAGING DETAILS*
ObjectOrion Constellation
ConstellationOrion
Distance243 to 1,360 light-years
Size594o2
Apparent MagnitudeVaries
  
Lens / Scope Canon 50mm f1.8  
MountSW AZ-EQ6 GT + EQASCOM computer control & Cartes du Ciel
GuidingNo Guiding
CameraCanon 550D modified
 FOV 25.5o x 17.7o Resolution 17.72”/ pixel      
Capture & ProcessingAstro Photography Tool + PHD2 Deep Sky Stacker, PixInsight, Photoshop CS3 & Topaz Denoise AI
Image Location &        OrientationCentre  RA 05:37:37.3      DEC +00:48:50.26         
Top = North    Right = West     
Exposures & Aperture42 x 120 sec  @ ISO800 Total: 1hr 24 min F1.8   
Calibration5 x 120’ Darks,  20 x 1/4000 sec Bias  20 x Flats         
Location & DarknessFairvale Observatory – Redhill – Surrey – UK        Typically Bortle 5-6
Date & Time10th February 2021  @ +21.00h  
WeatherApprox. <=0oC   RH <=65%                  🌙 NEW MOON

*For higher resolution and plate-solving data go to Astrobin HERE and click on image